When several actions related to an action concerning the organization of a general incorporated association, etc. for the same claim are pending simultaneously, the oral arguments and judicial decisions thereof must be made in consolidation.
第二百七十三条
(認容判決の効力が及ぶ者の範囲)Persons Affected by an Upholding Judgment
第一項
一般社団法人等の組織に関する訴えに係る請求を認容する確定判決は、第三者に対してもその効力を有する。
A final and binding judgment upholding a claim related to an action concerning the organization of a general incorporated association, etc. is also effective against third parties.
第二百七十四条
(無効又は取消しの判決の効力)Effects of a Judgment of Invalidation, Revocation or Rescission
When a judgment upholding a claim related to an action concerning the organization of a general incorporated association, etc. (limited to any one of the actions set forth in Article 269, item (i) through item (iii), item (vi) and item (vii)) becomes final and binding, the act that is held to be invalid or revoked or rescinded by that judgment (if a general incorporated association, etc. was incorporated in that act, it includes that incorporation) becomes ineffective from that time onwards.
第二百七十五条
(合併の無効判決の効力)Effects of a Judgment of Invalidation of a Merger
If a judgment upholding a claim related to an action seeking invalidation of any one of the acts set forth in the following items becomes final and binding, the general incorporated association, etc. that carried out that act is liable jointly and severally to perform the obligations assumed by the general incorporated associations, etc. specified respectively in those items after the day on which that act became effective:
一
一般社団法人等の吸収合併 吸収合併存続法人
absorption-type merger of a general incorporated association, etc.:the corporation surviving the absorption-type merger;
二
一般社団法人等の新設合併 新設合併設立法人
consolidation-type merger of a general incorporated association, etc.:the corporation incorporated through the consolidation-type merger.
In the cases prescribed in the preceding paragraph, the assets acquired, after the day on which the acts set forth in the items of that paragraph became effective, by the general incorporated associations, etc. specified respectively in those items, are co-owned by the general incorporated associations, etc. that carried out those acts.
In the cases prescribed in the two preceding paragraphs, the portion of the obligations to be assumed by each general incorporated association, etc. stated in paragraph (1) and share of co-ownership of assets stated in the preceding paragraph are decided through discussion among the general incorporated associations, etc.
If no agreement is reached in the discussion stated in the preceding paragraph with regard to the portion of the obligations to be assumed by each general incorporated association, etc. stated in paragraph (1) and share of co-ownership of assets stated in paragraph (2), the court comes to a decision, in response to a petition by each general incorporated association, etc., by taking into account the amount of assets held by each general incorporated association, etc. as of the time the act set forth in any one of the items of paragraph (1) became effective, and all other circumstances.
第二百七十六条
(設立の無効又は取消しの判決の効力)Effects of a Judgment of Invalidation or Rescission of the Incorporation of a General Incorporated Association
If a judgment upholding a claim related to an action seeking invalidation or rescission of the incorporation of a general incorporated association becomes final and binding, and the cause of the invalidation or rescission is attributable only to part of the members, the general incorporated association may continue in existence with the consent of all of the other members. In such a case, the members to whom the cause is attributable are deemed to have withdrawn.
The provisions of the first sentence of the preceding paragraph apply mutatis mutandis when a judgment upholding a claim related to an action seeking invalidation or rescission of the incorporation of a general incorporated foundation becomes final and binding. In such a case, the term "member" is deemed to be replaced with "founder".
第二百七十七条
(原告が敗訴した場合の損害賠償責任)Liability for Damages if the Plaintiff Loses an Action
If a plaintiff who filed an action concerning the organization of a general incorporated association, etc., loses the action, and the plaintiff acted in bad faith or with gross negligence, the plaintiff is jointly and severally liable to compensate the defendant for damages.
A member may request that the general incorporated association, in writing or by any other method prescribed by Ministry of Justice Order, file an action to enforce liability against members at incorporation, director at incorporation, and officers, etc. (meaning the officers, etc. prescribed in Article 111, paragraph (1); the same applies in paragraph (3)) or liquidator (hereinafter in this Subsection referred to as an "action to enforce liability"); provided, however, that this does not apply if the purpose of the liability action is to seek unlawful gains of that member or a third party or to inflict damages on that general incorporated association.
When the general incorporated association has not filed an action to enforce liability within sixty days from the day of a request made under the provisions of the preceding paragraph, the member who has made that request may file an action to enforce liability on behalf of the general incorporated association.
If the general incorporated association has not filed an action to enforce liability within sixty days from the day of the request made under the provisions of paragraph (1), and there is a request by the member who made that request or a member at incorporation, director at incorporation, officers, etc. or liquidator as stated in that paragraph, it must, without delay, notify the person who made the request of the reason for not filing the action to enforce liability, in writing or by any other method prescribed by Ministry of Justice Order.
Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraphs (1) and (2), if the general incorporated association is likely to suffer irreparable harm through the elapse of the period stated in paragraph (2), the member stated in paragraph (1) may immediately file an action to enforce liability on behalf of the general incorporated association; provided, however, that this does not apply in the cases prescribed in the proviso to paragraph (1).
The action to enforce liability stated in paragraph (2) or the preceding paragraph is deemed to be an action related to a claim which is not a claim on property rights when calculating the value of the action.
If a member files an action to enforce liability, the court may, in response to a petition by the defendant, order that member to provide reasonable security.
If the defendant intends to file the petition stated in the preceding paragraph, the defendant must make a prima facie showing that the action to enforce liability has been filed in bad faith.
第二百七十九条
(訴えの管轄)Jurisdiction of Actions
第一項
責任追及の訴えは、一般社団法人の主たる事務所の所在地を管轄する地方裁判所の管轄に専属する。
An action to enforce liability is under the exclusive jurisdiction of the district court with jurisdiction over the location of the principal office of the general incorporated association.
A member or a general incorporated association may participate in a legal action to enforce liability either as a co-party or to support either of the parties; provided, however, that this does not apply when this would unduly delay court proceedings or impose an excessive administrative burden on the court.
In order for a general incorporated association with auditor to participate in a legal action to enforce liability to support a director, liquidator or a person who was formerly in such a position, it must obtain the consent of the auditor (or, if there are two or more auditors, each auditor).
When a general incorporated association files an action to enforce liability, or receives the notice of legal action stated in the preceding paragraph, it must give notice thereof to its members without delay.
In order for a general incorporated association with auditor to settle in a lawsuit concerning an action to enforce liability against its directors and liquidators and persons who were formerly in such positions, it must obtain the consent of the auditor (or, if there are two or more auditors, each auditor).
The provisions of Article 267 of the Code of Civil Procedure do not apply to the subject-matter of an action to enforce liability if a general incorporated association is not a party to settlement in that action; provided, however, that this does not apply when that general incorporated association has given approval.
In cases prescribed in the preceding paragraph, the court must notify the general incorporated association of the contents of the settlement and give the general incorporated association notice to the effect that it should state its objection to the settlement, if any, within two weeks.
If the general incorporated association does not raise any objections in writing within the period referred to in the preceding paragraph, it is deemed to have given approval for members to effect a settlement within the contents of the notice given under the provisions of that paragraph.
The provisions of Article 25, Article 112 (including the cases where applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to Article 217, paragraph (4)), and Article 141, paragraph (5) (limited to the portion regarding obligations assumed for the portion not exceeding the excess amount prescribed in the proviso to that paragraph) do not apply in cases of effecting a settlement in an action to enforce liability.
If a member who has filed an action to enforce liability wins the action (including cases of partially winning the action), and that member has paid the necessary costs (excluding court costs) or is to pay a remuneration to an attorney, a legal professional corporation, or a lawyer and registered foreign lawyer joint corporation with respect to the liability action, the member may request that the general incorporated association pay an amount that is found to be reasonable and not exceeding the amount of those costs or the amount of the relevant remunerations.
Even if a member who has filed an action to enforce liability loses the case, the member is not obligated to compensate that general incorporated association for damages arising as a result thereof, except when that member was acting in bad faith.
第三項
前二項の規定は、第二百八十条第一項の規定により同項の訴訟に参加した社員について準用する。
The provisions of the preceding two paragraphs apply mutatis mutandis to any member who participates in a legal action pursuant to the provisions stated in Article 280, paragraph (1).
If an action to enforce liability has been filed, and the plaintiff and the defendant, in collusion, have caused the court to render a judgment for the purpose of prejudicing the rights of the general incorporated association which are the subject-matter of the liability action, the general incorporated association or members may enter an appeal against the judgment that becomes final and conclusive, by filing an action for a retrial.
第二項
前条の規定は、前項の再審の訴えについて準用する。
The provisions of the preceding Article apply mutatis mutandis to the appeal for retrial stated in the preceding paragraph.
第三款 一般社団法人等の役員等の解任の訴え
第二百八十四条
(一般社団法人等の役員等の解任の訴え)Actions Seeking Dismissal of an Officer, etc. of a General Incorporated Association, etc.
If, notwithstanding the presence of misconduct or material facts in violation of laws and regulations or the articles of incorporation in connection with the execution of the duties of a director, auditor, or councilor (hereinafter in this Subsection referred to as an "officer, etc."), a proposal to dismiss an officer, etc. is rejected at the general assembly meeting or the meeting of the board of councilors, the following persons may request dismissal of the officer, etc. by filing an action within thirty days from the day of the general assembly meeting or the meeting of the board of councilors:
members (excluding members who are directors or auditors regarding that request) holding not less than one-tenth (or, if a lesser ratio is prescribed in the articles of incorporation, that ratio) of the voting rights of all members (excluding members who are the director or auditor regarding that request); and