第六章 意見公募手続等
Chapter VI Public Comment Procedures
Article 38General Principles When Establishing Administrative Orders
The organ that establishes administrative orders or other orders (if administrative orders or other orders are established by Cabinet Decision, the minister in charge of drafting the administrative orders or other orders; referred to as "organs establishing administrative orders or other orders" below) must establish the administrative orders or other orders so that they will comply with the purpose of the laws and regulations which are to be the basis for the administrative orders or other orders.
After establishing administrative orders or other orders, organs establishing administrative orders or other orders must endeavor to maintain the appropriateness of the orders by taking into account of their implementation status and social and economic trends, and review the content of the administrative orders or other orders as necessary.
Article 39Public Comment Procedures
When an organ establishing administrative orders or other orders intends to establish administrative orders or other orders, it must publicize a draft of the orders (meaning a draft indicating the content to be established; the same applies below) and the materials relating to the administrative orders or other orders in advance and establish the place the comments (including information; the same applies below) are to be submitted, and the period for submitting comments (referred to as "period for submitting comments" below) and widely request comments from the general public.
The draft of the administrative orders or other orders to be publicized pursuant to the provisions of the preceding paragraph must have a concrete and clear content, and, must clearly indicate the title of the orders and the provisions of the laws and regulations which are to be the basis for them.
The period for submitting comments specified pursuant to the provisions of paragraph (1) must be 30 days or more commencing from the date of public notice referred to in that paragraph.
The provisions of paragraph (1) do not apply in cases that fall under any of the following items:
次の各号のいずれかに該当するときは、第一項の規定は、適用しない。
when it is difficult to take the procedures provided for in paragraph (1) (referred to as "public comment procedures" below) because it is necessary to urgently establish administrative orders or other orders in the public interest;
when intending to establish administrative orders or other orders that provide for the amount and the rate that serves as the basis for calculating the amount of money required to be paid and the calculation method for that amount which becomes necessary due to the establishment or amendment of laws providing for the money required to be paid, and administrative orders or other orders that provide for necessary matters concerning the implementation of those laws;
納付すべき金銭について定める法律の制定又は改正により必要となる当該金銭の額の算定の基礎となるべき金額及び率並びに算定方法についての命令等その他当該法律の施行に関し必要な事項を定める命令等を定めようとするとき。
when intending to establish administrative orders or other orders that provide for the amount and the rate that is to serves as the basis for calculating the amount that becomes necessary for making a decision to pay money as prescribed in the budget, and administrative orders or other orders that provide for other matters;
予算の定めるところにより金銭の給付決定を行うために必要となる当該金銭の額の算定の基礎となるべき金額及び率並びに算定方法その他の事項を定める命令等を定めようとするとき。
when intending to establish administrative orders or other orders that are to be established through considerations of the committee prescribed in Article 49, paragraph (1) or (2) of the Act for Establishment of the Cabinet Office or in Article 3, paragraph (2) of the National Government Organization Act, or the organ prescribed in Article 37 or Article 54 of the Act for Establishment of the Cabinet Office or in Article 8 of the National Government Organization Act (referred to as "committees or other councils"), pursuant to the provisions of laws, and that are specified by Cabinet Order for the purpose of adjusting the interests of persons with conflicting interests, pursuant to the provisions of laws or Cabinet Order, as those to be deliberated in the committees or other councils organized by each member representing those persons and the public interest;
法律の規定により、内閣府設置法第四十九条第一項若しくは第二項若しくは国家行政組織法第三条第二項に規定する委員会又は内閣府設置法第三十七条若しくは第五十四条若しくは国家行政組織法第八条に規定する機関(以下「委員会等」という。)の議を経て定めることとされている命令等であって、相反する利害を有する者の間の利害の調整を目的として、法律又は政令の規定により、これらの者及び公益をそれぞれ代表する委員をもって組織される委員会等において審議を行うこととされているものとして政令で定める命令等を定めようとするとき。
when intending to establish administrative orders or other orders that are practically the same as those that another administrative organ has established after conducting public comment procedures;
when intending to establish administrative orders or other orders that prescribe the technical replacement of terms necessary for applying or applying mutatis mutandis the provisions of laws and regulations, based on provisions of laws;
when intending to abolish administrative orders or other orders which should be abolished along with the deletion of the provisions of laws and regulations which are the basis for the administrative orders or other orders; or
when intending to establish administrative orders or other orders whose content is specified by Cabinet Order as an insignificant change that does not require the implementation of public comment procedures, such as the arrangement of provisions that are naturally required along with the establishment, amendment, or repeal of other laws and regulations.
Article 40Special Provisions on Public Comment Procedures
When intending to establish administrative orders or other orders, if there are compelling reasons for not being able to specify a minimum 30-day period for submitting comments, notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph (3) of the preceding Article, organs establishing administrative orders or other orders may specify a period for submitting comments that is less than 30 days. In such a case, the organs establishing administrative orders or other orders must clarify the reasons at the time of giving the public notice of the proposed administrative orders or other orders.
If organs establishing administrative orders intend to establish administrative orders or other orders through deliberation by the committees or other councils (except for cases that fall under paragraph (4), item (iv) of the preceding Article) and the committees or other councils has conducted a procedure equivalent to the public comment procedures, notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph (1) of that Article, they are not required to conduct the public comment procedures themselves.
Article 41Publicizing Public Comment Procedures
In conducting public comment procedures and establishing administrative orders or other orders, organs establishing administrative orders or other orders are to endeavor to publicize the implementation of the public comment procedures, and provide information on the implementation of the public comment procedures to the public, as necessary.
Article 42Consideration of Submitted Comments
In the case of conducting public comment procedures and establishing administrative orders or other orders, organs establishing administrative orders or other orders must sufficiently consider the comments submitted to them (referred to as "submitted comments" below) within the period for submitting comments.
Article 43Public Notice of Results
When an organ establishing administrative orders or other orders has conducted the public comment procedures and has established administrative orders or other orders, it must make the following matters public at the same time as the promulgation of the administrative orders or other orders (for those not to be promulgated, an act of making the administrative orders or other orders public; the same applies in paragraph (5));
the title of the administrative orders or other orders;
命令等の題名
the date of the public notice of the proposed administrative orders or other orders;
命令等の案の公示の日
the submitted comments (if there are no submitted comments, that fact); and
提出意見(提出意見がなかった場合にあっては、その旨)
the results after considering the submitted comments (including any differences between the proposed administrative orders or other orders for which the public comment procedures have been conducted and the established administrative orders or other orders), and the reasons for that.
Notwithstanding the provisions of the preceding paragraph, an organ establishing administrative orders or other orders may issue a public notice of the submitted comments that have been organized or summarized in lieu of the submitted comments referred to in item (iii) of that paragraph, as necessary. In such a case, the organ establishing administrative orders or other orders must publicize the submitted comments by keeping the administrative orders or other orders at the office of the organ establishing administrative orders or other orders, or by other appropriate means, without delay after the issuance of the public notice.
When there is a risk that the interests of a third party would be harmed by giving public notification of or making public the submitted comments pursuant to the provisions of the preceding two paragraphs, or when there are other legitimate grounds, an organ establishing administrative orders or other orders may exclude all or part of the submitted comments.
When an organ establishing administrative orders or other orders decides not to establish orders despite conducting the public comment procedures, the organ establishing administrative orders or other orders must promptly publicize that fact (if public comment procedures are to be conducted anew for other proposed administrative orders or other orders, including that fact) and the matters stated in items (i) and (ii) of paragraph (1).
When an organ establishing administrative orders or other orders has established administrative orders or other orders without conducting the public comment procedures due to falling under any of the items of Article 39, paragraph (4), it must make the following matters public at the same time as the promulgation of the administrative orders or other orders; provided, however, that the organs have publish the purpose of the administrative orders or other orders specified in item (i), only when the organs has not implemented the public comment procedures comment due to falling under any of the provisions of Article 39, paragraph (4), items (i) through (iv), and the purpose of the administrative orders or other orders is not obvious by the administrative orders or other orders.
the title and purpose of the administrative orders or other orders.;
命令等の題名及び趣旨
the fact that public comment procedures have not been conducted and the reasons for that.
意見公募手続を実施しなかった旨及びその理由
Article 44Application, Mutatis Mutandis
The provisions of Article 42 apply mutatis mutandis to cases in which an organ establishing administrative orders or other orders establishes the administrative orders or other orders without conducting the public comment procedures due to the case falling under Article 40, paragraph (2); the provisions of paragraphs (1) through (3) of the preceding Article apply mutatis mutandis to the case in which an organ establishing administrative orders or other orders has established the administrative orders or other orders without conducting the public comment procedures due to the case falling under Article 40, paragraph (2); and the provisions of paragraph (4) of the preceding Article apply mutatis mutandis to the case in which an organ establishing administrative orders or other orders has decided not to establish the administrative orders or other orders without conducting the public comment procedures due to the case falling under Article 40, paragraph (2). In these cases, the term "organs establishing administrative orders or other order" in Article 42 is deemed to be replaced by "committees or other councils", the term "the date of the public notice of the proposed administrative orders or other orders" in paragraph (1), item (ii) of the preceding Article is deemed to be replaced by "the date on which the committees or other councils have conducted a procedure equivalent to the public comment procedures concerning the proposed administrative orders or other orders", and the phrase "the public comment procedures have been conducted" in item (iv) of that paragraph is deemed to be replaced with "the procedure equivalent to the public comment procedures have been conducted by the committees or other councils ".
第四十二条の規定は第四十条第二項に該当することにより命令等制定機関が自ら意見公募手続を実施しないで命令等を定める場合について、前条第一項から第三項までの規定は第四十条第二項に該当することにより命令等制定機関が自ら意見公募手続を実施しないで命令等を定めた場合について、前条第四項の規定は第四十条第二項に該当することにより命令等制定機関が自ら意見公募手続を実施しないで命令等を定めないこととした場合について準用する。この場合において、第四十二条中「当該命令等制定機関」とあるのは「委員会等」と、前条第一項第二号中「命令等の案の公示の日」とあるのは「委員会等が命令等の案について公示に準じた手続を実施した日」と、同項第四号中「意見公募手続を実施した」とあるのは「委員会等が意見公募手続に準じた手続を実施した」と読み替えるものとする。
Article 45Means of Public Notice
The public notice under the provisions of Article 39, paragraph (1), and Article 43, paragraph (1) (including as applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to the preceding Article following the deemed replacement of terms), paragraph (4) (including as applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to the preceding Article), and paragraph (5) is to be provided by the means of using an electronic data processing system or other means using information and communications technology.
The Minister for Internal Affairs and Communications specifies the necessary matters concerning the public notice referred to in the preceding paragraph.
前項の公示に関し必要な事項は、総務大臣が定める。
定義第二条第一項第一号・法令全体に適用
法律、法律に基づく命令(告示を含む。)、条例及び地方公共団体の執行機関の規則(規程を含む。以下「規則」という。)
定義第二条第一項第五号・法令全体に適用
次に掲げる機関
わかりやすく言うと
国では、法律に基づき内閣に置かれる機関や内閣の所轄の下に置かれる機関、宮内庁、内閣府に置かれる委員会や庁、省・委員会・庁、会計検査院、これらに置かれる機関、これらの機関の職員のうち法律上独立して権限を行使することを認められた職員のことです。地方では、議会を除く地方公共団体の機関のことです。
定義第二条第一項第八号・法令全体に適用
内閣又は行政機関が定める次に掲げるもの
わかりやすく言うと
内閣または行政機関が定める次のもののことです。法律に基づく命令(処分の要件を定める告示を含む)と規則、申請された許認可等をするか法令に従って判断する審査基準、不利益処分をするかやその内容を判断する処分基準、同じ目的で複数の人に行政指導をするとき共通する内容である行政指導指針です。
略称規定第三十八条第一項
命令等を定める機関(閣議の決定により命令等が定められる場合にあっては、当該命令等の立案をする各大臣。以下「命令等制定機関」という。)は、命令等を定めるに当たっては…
わかりやすく言うと
命令等(法律に基づく命令や規則、審査基準、処分基準、行政指導指針)を定める機関のことです。閣議の決定によって命令等が定められる場合は、その命令等の案を作る各大臣を指します。
略称規定第三十九条第一項
…命令等を定めようとする場合には、当該命令等の案(命令等で定めようとする内容を示すものをいう。以下同じ。)及びこれに関連する資料をあらかじめ公示し、意見(情報を含む。以下同じ。)の提出先及び意見の提出のための期間(以下「意見提出期間」とい…
わかりやすく言うと
命令等を定めようとする機関が、その案と関連する資料を前もって公示して広く一般の意見を求めるときに定める、意見を提出するための期間のことです。
略称規定第三十九条第四項第一号
公益上、緊急に命令等を定める必要があるため、第一項の規定による手続(以下「意見公募手続」という。)を実施することが困難であるとき。
わかりやすく言うと
命令等を定めようとする機関が、その案と関連する資料を前もって公示し、意見の提出先と提出のための期間を定めて、広く一般から意見(情報を含む)を求める手続のことです(第三十九条第一項)。
略称規定第三十九条第四項第四号
法律の規定により、内閣府設置法第四十九条第一項若しくは第二項若しくは国家行政組織法第三条第二項に規定する委員会又は内閣府設置法第三十七条若しくは第五十四条若しくは国家行政組織法第八条に規定する機関(以下「委員会等」という。)の議を経て定め…
わかりやすく言うと
内閣府設置法第四十九条や国家行政組織法第三条第二項に基づいて置かれる委員会と、内閣府設置法第三十七条・第五十四条や国家行政組織法第八条が定める、審議会などの機関のことです。
略称規定第四十二条第一項
命令等制定機関は、意見公募手続を実施して命令等を定める場合には、意見提出期間内に当該命令等制定機関に対し提出された当該命令等の案についての意見(以下「提出意見」という。)を十分に考慮しなければならない。
わかりやすく言うと
意見公募手続で、意見提出期間内に命令等を定める機関に提出された、その命令等の案についての意見(情報を含む)のことです。機関は、意見公募手続を実施して命令等を定めるときは、これを十分に考慮しなければなりません。