Chapter III Requests for Review
第三章 審査請求等
Article 18Exclusion from Application of Provisions on Review Proceedings by Review Officers
第十八条(審理員による審理手続に関する規定の適用除外等)
The provisions of Article 9, Article 17, Article 24, Chapter II, Section 3 and Section 4, and Article 50, paragraph (2) of the Administrative Complaint Review Act (Act No. 68 of 2014) do not apply to a request for review of a disclosure or non-disclosure decision or an inaction related to a disclosure request.
In applying the provisions of Chapter II of the Administrative Complaint Review Act to a request for review of a disclosure or non-disclosure decision or an inaction related to a disclosure request, the phrase "a person who has been designated pursuant to the provisions of Article 9, paragraph (1) (referred to as a "review officer" below)" in Article 11, paragraph (2) of that Act is deemed to be replaced with "an administrative authority to which a request for review has been filed (including an administrative authority that has taken over documents and articles pursuant to the provisions of Article 14; referred to as "reviewing agency" below) pursuant to the provisions of Article 4 (including the Cabinet Order based on Article 20, paragraph (2) of the Act on Access to Information Held by Administrative Organs (Act No. 42 of 1999)); the term "review officer" in Article 13, paragraphs (1) and (2) of that Act is deemed to be replaced with "reviewing agency"; the term "has been filed or a written opinion stating that a stay of execution prescribed in Article 40 should be issued has been submitted by a review officer" in Article 25, paragraph (7) of that Act is deemed to be replaced with "has been filed"; the terms "Administrative Complaint Review Board, etc." and "has received a report to its consultation from the Administrative Complaint Review Board, etc. (or when a review officer's written opinion has been submitted in the case where the consultation pursuant to the provisions of paragraph (1) of the preceding Article is not necessary (excluding the cases falling under item (ii) or (iii) of the relevant paragraph), or when deliberations prescribed in item (ii) or (iii) of the relevant paragraph have been held in the cases falling under item (ii) or (iii) of the relevant paragraph) in Article 44 of that Act are deemed to be replaced with "Information Disclosure and Personal Information Protection Review Board (if the President of the Board of Audit is the reviewing agency, a review board specified separately by laws; the same applies in Article 50, paragraph (1), item (iv))" and "has received a report to its consultation from the Administrative Complaint Review Board, etc.", respectively; and the phrase "the review officer's written opinion or the written report from the Administrative Complaint Review Board, etc. or the Council, etc." in Article 50, paragraph (1), item (iv) of that Act is deemed to be replaced with "Information Disclosure and Personal Information Protection Review Board".
開示決定等又は開示請求に係る不作為に係る審査請求についての行政不服審査法第二章の規定の適用については、同法第十一条第二項中「第九条第一項の規定により指名された者(以下「審理員」という。)」とあるのは「第四条(行政機関の保有する情報の公開に関する法律(平成十一年法律第四十二号)第二十条第二項の規定に基づく政令を含む。)の規定により審査請求がされた行政庁(第十四条の規定により引継ぎを受けた行政庁を含む。以下「審査庁」という。)」と、同法第十三条第一項及び第二項中「審理員」とあるのは「審査庁」と、同法第二十五条第七項中「あったとき、又は審理員から第四十条に規定する執行停止をすべき旨の意見書が提出されたとき」とあるのは「あったとき」と、同法第四十四条中「行政不服審査会等」とあるのは「情報公開・個人情報保護審査会(審査庁が会計検査院の長である場合にあっては、別に法律で定める審査会。第五十条第一項第四号において同じ。)」と、「受けたとき(前条第一項の規定による諮問を要しない場合(同項第二号又は第三号に該当する場合を除く。)にあっては審理員意見書が提出されたとき、同項第二号又は第三号に該当する場合にあっては同項第二号又は第三号に規定する議を経たとき)」とあるのは「受けたとき」と、同法第五十条第一項第四号中「審理員意見書又は行政不服審査会等若しくは審議会等」とあるのは「情報公開・個人情報保護審査会」とする。
Article 19Consultation with the Review Board
第十九条(審査会への諮問)
When there is a request for review related to a disclosure or non-disclosure decision or an inaction related to a disclosure request, the head of the administrative organ who should make an administrative determination on the request for review must consult with the Information Disclosure and Personal Information Protection Review Board (when the head of the administrative organ who should make an administrative determination on the request for review is the President of the Board of Audit, a review board specified separately by laws), unless the case falls under either of the following cases:
if the request for review is not in accordance with the law and is to be dismissed; or
審査請求が不適法であり、却下する場合
if the entire request for review has been approved by an administrative determination, and it is decided that all of the administrative documents related to the request for review is to be disclosed (excluding the cases in which a written opposition opinion on the disclosure of the administrative documents has been submitted).
The head of an administrative organ who has made a consultation pursuant to the provisions of the preceding paragraph must notify the following persons of the fact that a consultation has been made.
the requestor for review and intervenor (meaning the intervenor prescribed in Article 13, paragraph (4) of the Administrative Complaint Review Act; the same applies below in this paragraph and paragraph (1), item (ii) of the following Article);
審査請求人及び参加人(行政不服審査法第十三条第四項に規定する参加人をいう。以下この項及び次条第一項第二号において同じ。)
the disclosure requester (except when the person is the requestor for review or an intervenor); and
a third party that has submitted a written opposition opinion on the disclosure of the administrative documents related to the request for review (excluding the cases in which the third party is the requestor for review or an intervenor).
Article 20Procedures When Dismissing Requests for Review from Third Parties
第二十条(第三者からの審査請求を棄却する場合等における手続等)
The provisions of Article 13, paragraph (3) apply mutatis mutandis to the cases in which the administrative determination falls under any of the following items:
第十三条第三項の規定は、次の各号のいずれかに該当する裁決をする場合について準用する。
an administrative determination to dismiss or reject the request for review from a third party against a disclosure decision;
an administrative determination to change the disclosure or non-disclosure decision related to a request for review (excluding a decision to disclose all of the administrative documents related to a request for disclosure), and to disclose the administrative documents related to that request for review (limited to the case in which an intervenor who is a third party has manifested the intention to oppose the disclosure of the administrative documents).
Concerning a request for review of a disclosure decision, etc. or of any inaction related to a disclosure request, special provisions for the provisions of Article 4 of the Administrative Complaint Review Act may be established pursuant to the provisions of Cabinet Order
開示決定等又は開示請求に係る不作為についての審査請求については、政令で定めるところにより、行政不服審査法第四条の規定の特例を設けることができる。
Article 21Special Provisions on the Transfer of Litigations
第二十一条(訴訟の移送の特例)
When a litigation demanding revocation of a disclosure or non-disclosure decision, or revocation of an administrative determination on a request for review related to a disclosure or non-disclosure decision or an inaction related to a request for disclosure (referred to as "information disclosure litigation" in the following paragraph and paragraph (2) of the Supplementary Provisions) has been filed to the specified court with jurisdiction prescribed in Article 12, paragraph (4) of the Administrative Case Litigation Act (Act No. 139 of 1962), notwithstanding the provisions of Article 12, paragraph (5) of that Act, if an action for judicial review (meaning an action for judicial review prescribed in Article 3, paragraph (1) of that Act; the same applies in the following paragraph) on a disclosure or non-disclosure decision or an inaction related to a disclosure or non-disclosure decision or a request for disclosure for the same, or the same type or similar administrative documents is pending at another court, if the specified court with jurisdiction finds it appropriate in consideration of the address or location of the party, the address of witness to be examined, commonality of the issues or evidence, and other circumstances, the court may transfer all or a part of the litigation to that other court or a court prescribed in Article 12, paragraphs (1) through (3) of that Act, in response to a proposal or by its own authority.
行政事件訴訟法(昭和三十七年法律第百三十九号)第十二条第四項の規定により同項に規定する特定管轄裁判所に開示決定等の取消しを求める訴訟又は開示決定等若しくは開示請求に係る不作為に係る審査請求に対する裁決の取消しを求める訴訟(次項及び附則第二項において「情報公開訴訟」という。)が提起された場合においては、同法第十二条第五項の規定にかかわらず、他の裁判所に同一又は同種若しくは類似の行政文書に係る開示決定等又は開示決定等若しくは開示請求に係る不作為に係る審査請求に対する裁決に係る抗告訴訟(同法第三条第一項に規定する抗告訴訟をいう。次項において同じ。)が係属しているときは、当該特定管轄裁判所は、当事者の住所又は所在地、尋問を受けるべき証人の住所、争点又は証拠の共通性その他の事情を考慮して、相当と認めるときは、申立てにより又は職権で、訴訟の全部又は一部について、当該他の裁判所又は同法第十二条第一項から第三項までに定める裁判所に移送することができる。
The provisions of the preceding paragraph apply mutatis mutandis to the cases in which an action for judicial review on a disclosure or non-disclosure decision or an administrative determination on a request for review of a disclosure or non-disclosure decision or an inaction related to the disclosure request, other than an information disclosure lawsuit, has been filed to the specified court with jurisdiction prescribed in Article 12, paragraph (4) of the Administrative Case Litigation Act pursuant to the provisions of that paragraph.
administrative document
「行政文書」
Documents, drawings and electronic or magnetic records (電磁的記録) that employees of an administrative organ (行政機関) have made or obtained in their work and that the organ holds for its employees' organizational use, except publications issued for sale to the general public such as the official gazette (官報), white papers and books; specified historical public records (特定歴史公文書等), the historical records moved to, or donated to or deposited with, the National Archives (国立公文書館) and similar archives under the Public Records and Archives Management Act; and materials under special management as historical, cultural or research materials at research institutes and other facilities a Cabinet Order (政令) names.
Defined inArticle 2, paragraph (2)· applies throughout the law
head of an administrative organmachine translation
「行政機関の長」
The head of an administrative organ (行政機関), to whom anyone may make a request for disclosure of the administrative documents (行政文書) that organ holds; for the organs a Cabinet Order (政令) designates under Article 2, paragraph (1), items (iv) and (v), it is instead the person a Cabinet Order names for each of those organs.
Defined inArticle 3, paragraph (1)
request for disclosure
「開示請求」
A request, which anyone may make under Article 3 by submitting a written request for disclosure (開示請求書) to the head of an administrative organ (行政機関), for disclosure of an administrative document (行政文書) that organ holds.
Short name set inArticle 4, paragraph (1)
disclosure requester
「開示請求者」
A person who has made a request for disclosure (開示請求) of an administrative document (行政文書) under this Act.
Short name set inArticle 4, paragraph (2)
decision on disclosure or non-disclosure
「開示決定等」
A decision by the head of an administrative organ (行政機関) under Article 9 on a request for disclosure (開示請求): to disclose all or part of the requested administrative document (行政文書), or to disclose none of it, including where the request is refused under Article 8 or the organ does not hold the document.
Short name set inArticle 10, paragraph (1)
disclosure decision
「開示決定」
A decision by the head of an administrative organ (行政機関) under Article 9(1) to disclose all or part of a requested administrative document (行政文書).
Short name set inArticle 12, paragraph (3)
third party
「第三者」
In Article 13, Article 19(2) and Article 20(1), any person or body other than the national government (国), incorporated administrative agencies, etc. (独立行政法人等), local governments (地方公共団体), local incorporated administrative agencies (地方独立行政法人) and the disclosure requester (開示請求者).
Short name set inArticle 13, paragraph (1)· applies only in this article and in Article 19, paragraph (2); and Article 20, paragraph (1)
written opposition opinion
「反対意見書」
A written opinion (意見書) in which a third party (第三者), given the chance under Article 13(1) or (2) to comment on a request for disclosure (開示請求), states that it opposes disclosure of the administrative document (行政文書).
Short name set inArticle 13, paragraph (3)· applies only in this provision and in Article 19
reviewing agencymachine translation
「審査庁」
The administrative authority (行政庁) with which a request for review (審査請求) of a decision on disclosure or non-disclosure (開示決定等), or of a failure to act on a request for disclosure (開示請求), has been filed under Article 4 of the Administrative Complaint Review Act or a Cabinet Order (政令) under Article 20(2) of this Act, including one that took the case over under Article 14 of that Act when the power to decide it passed to it through a change in the law.
Short name set inArticle 18, paragraph (2)
intervenorcorrected by this site
「参加人」
A person, other than the one who filed a request for review (審査請求) of a decision on disclosure or non-disclosure (開示決定等) or of a failure to act on a request for disclosure (開示請求), who is found, in light of the laws the disposition (処分) rests on, to have an interest in it and who takes part in the review with the permission or at the request of the reviewing agency (審査庁), under Article 13 of the Administrative Complaint Review Act as Article 18(2) of this Act applies it.
Defined inArticle 19, paragraph (2), item (i)· applies only in this paragraph and in Article 20, paragraph (1), item (ii)
information disclosure litigation
「情報公開訴訟」
A lawsuit (訴訟) filed in a specified court with jurisdiction (特定管轄裁判所) under Article 12(4) of the Administrative Case Litigation Act, that is, the district court at the seat of the high court whose district covers the plaintiff's general forum (普通裁判籍), seeking revocation of a decision on disclosure or non-disclosure (開示決定等), or of a ruling (裁決) on a request for review (審査請求) of such a decision or of a failure to act on a request for disclosure (開示請求).
Short name set inArticle 21, paragraph (1)· applies only in this provision and in Article 21, paragraph (2)
action for judicial review
「抗告訴訟」
In Article 21, a lawsuit (訴訟) challenging an administrative agency's (行政庁) exercise of public power, as Article 3(1) of the Administrative Case Litigation Act defines it.
Defined inArticle 21, paragraph (1)· applies only in this provision and in Article 21, paragraph (2)
Administrative Complaint Review Board
行政不服審査会
A board set up in the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications (総務省) to deal with the matters the Administrative Complaint Review Act puts in its charge (Administrative Complaint Review Act, Article 67). Where the agency deciding a request for review (審査請求) is the competent minister (主任の大臣), the Grand Steward of the Imperial Household Agency (宮内庁長官) or the head of certain agencies, it must as a rule consult the board once the review officer (審理員) has handed in an opinion — but not, among other cases, where a council already deliberated on the disposition (処分), where the person requesting the review has said they do not want the board consulted and no intervenor (参加人) objects, where the request is unlawful and is dismissed, or where a disposition other than one refusing an application is to be revoked in full, or an application is to be granted in full, and no one has opposed that; where the agency is the head of a local government (地方公共団体), it consults a body the local government sets up instead (Articles 43, paragraph (1), and 81). Another Act can send the consultation to a body of its own instead, or do without it: a request for review of a decision on disclosure under the Act on Access to Information Held by Administrative Organs is put to the Information Disclosure and Personal Information Protection Review Board (情報公開・個人情報保護審査会) (Act on Access to Information Held by Administrative Organs, Articles 18, paragraph (2), and 19, paragraph (1); Administrative Complaint Review Act, Article 1, paragraph (2)). The board has nine members, part-time, though up to three may be full-time (Article 68), appointed by the Minister of Internal Affairs and Communications (総務大臣), with the consent of both Houses of the Diet (国会), from people who can judge fairly and have outstanding insight into law or administration, for three years (Article 69, paragraphs (1) and (4)). It examines each case in a panel of three members it names, or of all its members where it so decides (Article 72). When it has answered a consultation, it sends a copy of its written report (答申書) to the person who requested the review and to any intervenor, and makes the report public (Article 79). The agency that consulted it must then make its determination (裁決) without delay, and where the determination's conclusion differs from the report, it must give the reasons for that (Articles 44 and 50, paragraph (1), item (iv)).
Written by AI using Administrative Complaint Review Act, Arts. 43, 44, 50, 67, 68, 69, 72, 79, 81 and Act on Access to Information Held by Administrative Organs, Arts. 18, 19 as a reference.
Information Disclosure and Personal Information Protection Review Board
情報公開・個人情報保護審査会
A board set up in the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications (総務省) to examine a request for review (審査請求) when the body that must decide it consults the board under the Act on Access to Information Held by Administrative Organs, the Act on Access to Information Held by Incorporated Administrative Agencies or the Act on the Protection of Personal Information (Act for Establishment of the Information Disclosure and Personal Information Protection Review Board, Article 2). Its fifteen members are appointed by the Prime Minister (内閣総理大臣), with the consent of both Houses of the Diet (国会), from people of outstanding insight (Articles 3 and 4, paragraph (1)). When it considers it necessary, it can have the body consulting it show it the documents or the personal information themselves, which that body may not refuse, and no one may ask the board to disclose what it is shown (Article 9, paragraphs (1) and (2)). When it has answered a consultation, it sends a copy of its written report (答申書) to the person who requested the review and to anyone who has joined the review as a party (参加人, an intervenor), and makes the content of its report public (Article 16). The head of an administrative organ who must decide a request for review of a decision on disclosure, or of a failure to decide, must consult it first, unless the request is unlawful and is dismissed, or it is granted in full and all the documents are to be disclosed with no third party having submitted a written objection to their disclosure (反対意見書). When the head is the President of the Board of Audit (会計検査院), a board set up by a separate Act is consulted instead (Act on Access to Information Held by Administrative Organs, Article 19, paragraph (1)).
Written by AI using Act for Establishment of the Information Disclosure and Personal Information Protection Review Board, Arts. 2, 3, 4, 9, 16 and Act on Access to Information Held by Administrative Organs, Art. 19 as a reference.
request for review
審査請求
A request to an administrative agency (行政庁) to review a disposition (処分) the person objects to, or, where the person applied for a disposition under a law or regulation and a reasonable time has passed with none made, the agency's failure to act (不作為) (Administrative Complaint Review Act, Articles 2 and 3). Unless an Act, or for a disposition based on a local ordinance (条例) that ordinance, provides otherwise, it is made to the agency that made the disposition or failed to act where that agency has no superior agency or is itself the competent minister (主任の大臣) or the head of certain agencies; where such a minister or head is the agency above it, to that minister or head; and otherwise to its highest superior agency (Article 4). Another Act can set rules of its own for it, naming another body to make it to or another route (Article 1, paragraph (2); Article 4): the Employees' Pension Insurance Act, for instance, has a request about a disposition (処分) of the Minister of Health, Labour and Welfare (厚生労働大臣) on a person's status as insured, standard remuneration or insurance benefits, other than a decision on a request to correct the pension insurance register, made to a social insurance examiner (社会保険審査官), and disapplies most of the Administrative Complaint Review Act's rules for it (Employees' Pension Insurance Act, Articles 90, paragraph (1), and 91-2). Under the Administrative Complaint Review Act, a request about a disposition must be made within three months of the day after the person learned of it — or one month after learning of the decision, where a request for re-investigation (再調査の請求) was made first — and within a year of the disposition or that decision, unless there is a justifiable reason (Administrative Complaint Review Act, Article 18, paragraphs (1) and (2)). Making one does not by itself stop the disposition taking effect or being carried out, or the proceedings going on (Article 25, paragraph (1)), but the agency reviewing it can suspend them in whole or in part on the application of the person who made the request — and, where it made the disposition or is the agency above the one that did, of its own motion — and, once the person who made the request has applied, must where that is urgently needed to avoid serious harm, unless that would seriously affect the public welfare or the request appears to have no grounds (Article 25, paragraphs (2) to (4)). The agency reviewing it (審査庁) decides it by a determination (裁決): it dismisses a request that is unlawful, for instance one made too late, rejects one that is groundless, and, where one is well founded, revokes the disposition in whole or in part or changes it — though never to the disadvantage of the person who made the request, and an agency that neither made the disposition nor is above the agency that did cannot change it (Articles 45, paragraphs (1) and (2), 46, paragraph (1), and 48). Where the request is about a de facto act (事実上の行為), the determination instead declares the act unlawful or unjust and orders it abolished in whole or in part or changed, or abolishes or changes it (Article 47). A well-founded request about a failure to act ends instead in a determination declaring the failure unlawful or unjust, and, where the agency finds a disposition should be made, an order to make it or the disposition itself (Article 49, paragraph (3)). Where revoking an unlawful or unjust disposition, or abolishing an unlawful or unjust de facto act, would seriously harm the public interest, the agency can reject the request while declaring in the determination that it is unlawful or unjust (Article 45, paragraph (3)). The determination takes effect when it is served on the person who made the request — or, where someone other than the disposition's addressee made it and the determination revokes or changes the disposition or deals with a de facto act, once it is served on the addressee too — and binds the agencies concerned (Articles 51, paragraph (1), and 52, paragraph (1)).
Written by AI using Administrative Complaint Review Act, Arts. 1 to 4, 18, 25, 45 to 49, 51, 52 and Employees' Pension Insurance Act, Arts. 90, 91-2 as a reference.