Chapter IV Labour Relations Commission
第四章 労働委員会
Section 1 Establishment, Duties, and Administrative Affairs under the Jurisdiction, Organizations, and Related Matters
第一節 設置、任務及び所掌事務並びに組織等
Article 19Labour Relations Commission
第十九条(労働委員会)
A Labour Relations Commission is to be composed of equal numbers of persons representing employers (hereinafter referred to as "employer members"), persons representing workers (hereinafter referred to as "labor members"), and persons representing the public interest (hereinafter referred to as "public interest members").
労働委員会は、使用者を代表する者(以下「使用者委員」という。)、労働者を代表する者(以下「労働者委員」という。)及び公益を代表する者(以下「公益委員」という。)各同数をもつて組織する。
The Labour Relations Commissions are to consist of the Central Labour Relations Commission and Prefectural Labour Relations Commissions.
労働委員会は、中央労働委員会及び都道府県労働委員会とする。
The particulars concerning the Labour Relations Commission in addition to what is provided for in this Act are to be prescribed by Cabinet Order.
労働委員会に関する事項は、この法律に定めるもののほか、政令で定める。
Article 19-2Central Labour Relations Commission
第十九条の二(中央労働委員会)
The Central Labour Relations Commission is established under the jurisdiction of the Minister of Health, Labour and Welfare based on the provisions of Article 3, paragraph (2) of the National Government Organization Act (Act No. 120 of 1948).
国家行政組織法(昭和二十三年法律第百二十号)第三条第二項の規定に基づいて、厚生労働大臣の所轄の下に、中央労働委員会を置く。
The Central Labour Relations Commission has the duty to defend the workers' uniting and promote the fair adjustment of labor relationships.
中央労働委員会は、労働者が団結することを擁護し、及び労働関係の公正な調整を図ることを任務とする。
In order to fulfill the duties set forth in the preceding paragraph, the Central Labour Relations Commission takes charge of affairs set forth in the provisions of Article 5, Article 11, Article 18, and Article 26 of this Act, administrative affairs concerning examination, etc., cases of unfair labor practice, (meaning the disposition of cases pursuant to the provisions of Article 7, the following Section, and Section 3 of this Act; the same applies hereinafter), administrative affairs concerning the conciliation, mediation, and arbitration of labor disputes, administrative affairs pursuant to the provisions of Article 35-2 and Article 35-3 of the Labor Relations Adjustment Act, and other administrative affairs belonging to the Central Labour Relations Commission based on other laws (including orders based on laws).
Article 19-3Appointment of the Members of the Central Labour5 Relations Commission
第十九条の三(中央労働委員会の委員の任命等)
The Central Labour Relations Commission is to be composed of fifteen members from employer members, labor members, and public interest members.
The Prime Minister appoints the employer members based upon the recommendations of employers' organizations (for four of the employer members, based upon the recommendations of agencies engaged in administrative execution (meaning an agency engaged in administrative execution provided for in Article 2, paragraph (4) of the Act on General Rules for Incorporated Administrative Agencies (Act No. 103 of 1999); the same applies in this paragraph, paragraph (2), item (ii) of the following Article, and Article 19-10, paragraph (1))). The Prime Minister appoints the labor members based upon the recommendations of the labor unions (for four of the labor members, based upon the recommendations of the labor unions formed or joined by employees provided for in Article 2, item (ii) of the Act on Labor Relations of Agency Engaged in Administrative Execution (Act No. 257 of 1948) (hereinafter referred to as "employees of an agency engaged in administrative execution" in this Chapter)). The Prime Minister, after obtaining the consent of both Houses, appoints the public interest members from among the persons stated in the list of candidates prepared by the Minister of Health, Labor and Welfare with the consent of the employer members and the labor members.
使用者委員は使用者団体の推薦(使用者委員のうち四人については、行政執行法人(独立行政法人通則法(平成十一年法律第百三号)第二条第四項に規定する行政執行法人をいう。以下この項、次条第二項第二号及び第十九条の十第一項において同じ。)の推薦)に基づいて、労働者委員は労働組合の推薦(労働者委員のうち四人については、行政執行法人の労働関係に関する法律(昭和二十三年法律第二百五十七号)第二条第二号に規定する職員(以下この章において「行政執行法人職員」という。)が結成し、又は加入する労働組合の推薦)に基づいて、公益委員は厚生労働大臣が使用者委員及び労働者委員の同意を得て作成した委員候補者名簿に記載されている者のうちから両議院の同意を得て、内閣総理大臣が任命する。
In the case where the term of office of a public interest member has expired or a vacancy has occurred for a public interest member and the consent of both Houses cannot be obtained because the Diet is not in session or the House of Representatives has been dissolved, notwithstanding the provisions of the preceding paragraph, the Prime Minister may appoint a public interest member from among the persons stated in the list of candidates prepared by the Minister of Health, Labor and Welfare after obtaining the consent of the employer members and the labor members.
In the case referred to in the preceding paragraph, subsequent approval by both Houses must be sought at the first session of the Diet after the appointment. In this case, if subsequent approval of both Houses cannot be obtained, the Prime Minister must immediately dismiss the public interest member.
As to appointment of the public interest members, seven or more those members must not belong to the same political party.
公益委員の任命については、そのうち七人以上が同一の政党に属することとなつてはならない。
The members of the Central Labour Relations Commission (simply referred to as "members" in the following Article to Article 19-9) is to serve on a part-time basis; provided, however, that up to two public interest members may serve on a full-time basis.
Article 19-4Disqualification Clause of Members
第十九条の四(委員の欠格条項)
A person who has been sentenced to punishment of imprisonment or a greater punishment, and who is still under the execution of the sentence or who has not ceased to be subject to the execution of the sentence, may not become a member.
拘禁刑以上の刑に処せられ、その執行を終わるまで、又は執行を受けることがなくなるまでの者は、委員となることができない。
A person who falls under any of the following items may not become a public interest member:
次の各号のいずれかに該当する者は、公益委員となることができない。
a member of the Diet or a member of the assembly of a local government;
国会又は地方公共団体の議会の議員
an officer of an agency engaged in administrative execution, an employee of an agency engaged in administrative execution, or a member or officer of a labor union formed or joined by employees of an agency engaged in administrative execution;
Article 19-5Term of Office of Members
第十九条の五(委員の任期等)
Article 19-6Services of Public Interest Members
第十九条の六(公益委員の服務)
A public interest member serving full-time may not perform any act falling under any of the following items while in office:
常勤の公益委員は、在任中、次の各号のいずれかに該当する行為をしてはならない。
to become an officer of a political party or other political organizations, or actively engage in political activities;
政党その他の政治的団体の役員となり、又は積極的に政治運動をすること。
except in cases permitted by the Prime Minister, to receive remuneration and engage in any other duty, undertake a business for profit, or otherwise engage in any business for pecuniary profit.
内閣総理大臣の許可のある場合を除くほか、報酬を得て他の職務に従事し、又は営利事業を営み、その他金銭上の利益を目的とする業務を行うこと。
A public interest member serving part-time may not perform any act falling under item (i) of the preceding paragraph while in office.
Article 19-7Loss of Job and Dismissal of a Member
第十九条の七(委員の失職及び罷免)
A member loses their job in the case where the member comes to fall under any of the items of Article 19-4, paragraph (1). The same applies in the case where a public interest member comes to fall under any of the items of paragraph (2) of the same Article.
When the Prime Minister finds that a member cannot execute their duties by reason of mental or physical disorder, a member has breached their duties, or a member has committed a misconduct unbefitting for a member, the Prime Minister may dismiss the member with the consent of the Central Labour Relations Commission in the case of an employer member or a labor member, or with the consent of both Houses in the case of a public interest member.
Pursuant to the provisions of the preceding paragraph, if the Prime Minister has requested the Central Labour Relations Commission to give its consent to the dismissal of an employer member or a labor member, the member may not take part in the decision.
The Prime Minister is to immediately dismiss a public interest member who has newly come to belong to a political party to which six of the other public interest members already belong.
内閣総理大臣は、公益委員のうち六人が既に属している政党に新たに属するに至つた公益委員を直ちに罷免するものとする。
If seven or more public interest members have come to belong to the same political party (excluding cases which fall under the provisions of the preceding paragraph), with the consent of both Houses, the Prime Minister is to dismiss public interest members so that the number of public interest members belonging to the same party is six; provided, however, that the Prime Minister may not dismiss members who have not changed the political party to which they belong.
Article 19-8Remuneration of the Members
第十九条の八(委員の給与等)
Article 19-9Chairperson of the Central Labour Relations Commission
第十九条の九(中央労働委員会の会長)
The Central Labour Relations Commission is to have a chairperson.
中央労働委員会に会長を置く。
The chairperson is elected by the members from among the public interest members.
The chairperson presides over the business of the Central Labour Relations Commission and represents the Central Labour Relations Commission.
会長は、中央労働委員会の会務を総理し、中央労働委員会を代表する。
The Central Labour Relations Commission must designate in advance a member, by election by the members from among the public interest members, who acts on behalf of the chairperson in the case the chairperson is impeded from performing their duties.
Article 19-10Local Members for Adjustment
第十九条の十(地方調整委員)
Local members for adjustment are to be established within the Central Labour Relations Commission representing the employers, the workers, and the public interest, to participate in conciliation or mediation in disputes and other cases arising between an agency engaged in administrative execution and the employees of an agency engaged in administrative execution employed by it, as well as other disputes or other cases as provided for by Cabinet Order as those to be dealt with locally by the Central Labour Relations Commission; and to participate in procedures as provided for in Article 24-2, paragraph (5).
中央労働委員会に、行政執行法人とその行政執行法人職員との間に発生した紛争その他の事件で地方において中央労働委員会が処理すべきものとして政令で定めるものに係るあつせん若しくは調停又は第二十四条の二第五項の規定による手続に参与させるため、使用者、労働者及び公益をそれぞれ代表する地方調整委員を置く。
The Minister of Health, Labor and Welfare appoints local members for adjustment with the consent of the Central Labour Relations Commission for each district specified by Cabinet Order.
地方調整委員は、中央労働委員会の同意を得て、政令で定める区域ごとに厚生労働大臣が任命する。
The provisions of the main clause of Article 19-5, paragraph (1) and paragraph (2); Article 19-7, paragraph (2); and Article 19-8 apply mutatis mutandis to the local members for adjustment. In this case, the term "the Prime Minister" in Article 19-7, paragraph (2), is deemed to be replaced with "the Minister of Health, Labour and Welfare"; and the phrase "with the consent of the Central Labour Relations Commission in the case of an employer member or a labor member, or with the consent of both Houses in the case of a public interest member" in the same paragraph is deemed to be replaced with "with the consent of the Central Labour Relations Commission."
Article 19-11Secretariat of the Central Labour Relations Commission
第十九条の十一(中央労働委員会の事務局)
A secretariat is to be established within the Central Labour Relations Commission to organize the administrative affairs of the Commission, and the secretariat is to have a director-general and other necessary staff members appointed by the Minister of Health, Labor and Welfare with the consent of the chairperson.
中央労働委員会にその事務を整理させるために事務局を置き、事務局に会長の同意を得て厚生労働大臣が任命する事務局長及び必要な職員を置く。
A local office that takes charge of administrative affairs in the local area is to be established in the secretariat.
事務局に、地方における事務を分掌させるため、地方事務所を置く。
The location, name, and jurisdictional district of a local office are prescribed by Cabinet Order.
地方事務所の位置、名称及び管轄区域は、政令で定める。
Article 19-12Prefectural Labour Relations Commission
第十九条の十二(都道府県労働委員会)
A Prefectural Labour Relations Commission is established under the jurisdiction of the prefectural governor.
都道府県知事の所轄の下に、都道府県労働委員会を置く。
The Prefectural Labour Relations Commission is to be composed of thirteen members each, eleven members each, nine members each, seven members each, or five members each for employer members, labor members, and public interest members, respectively, for the number as specified by Cabinet Order; provided, however, that it may be composed of the number of members adding two members each of employer members, labor members, and public interest members to the number specified by Cabinet Order, pursuant to the provisions of Prefectural Order.
The prefectural governor appoints the employer members based upon the recommendations of the employers' organizations, the labor members based upon the recommendations of the labor unions, and the public interest members with the consent of the employer members and the labor members.
The appointment of public interest members is to be made in accordance with the number of public interest members listed in the left-hand column of the Appended Table for the Prefectural Labour Relations Commission (for Prefectural Labour Relations Commissions composed of members with two members added to the number specified by Cabinet Order pursuant to the proviso to paragraph 2 of this Article, the number of public interest members that added those two members ), and the number of public interest members exceeding the number specified in the right-hand column of the Table must not belong to the same political party.
When a public interest member has contravened the provisions of the preceding paragraph due to their actions, the member is to retire as a matter of course.
The provisions of Article 19-3, paragraph (6); Article 19-4, paragraph (1); Article 19-5; Article 19-7, the first sentence of paragraph (1), paragraph (2) and paragraph (3); Article 19-8; Article 19-9; and paragraph (1) of the preceding Article apply mutatis mutandis to Prefectural Labour Relations Commissions. In this case, the term "on a full-time basis" in the proviso to Article 19-3, paragraph (6) is deemed to be replaced with "on a full-time basis pursuant to the provisions of Prefectural Order"; "the Prime Minister" in Article 19-7, paragraph (2) is deemed to be replaced with "the prefectural governor"; "with the consent of the Central Labour Relations Commission in the case of an employer member or a labor member, or with the consent of both Houses in the case of a public interest member" in the same paragraph is deemed to be replaced with "the Prefectural Labour Relations Commission"; "the Prime Minister" in paragraph 3 of the same Article is deemed to be replaced with "the prefectural governor"; "an employer member or a labor member" in the same paragraph is deemed to be replaced with "a member of the Prefectural Labour Relations Commission"; and "the Minister of Health, Labor and Welfare" in paragraph (1) of the preceding Article is deemed to be replaced with "the prefectural governor."
第十九条の三第六項、第十九条の四第一項、第十九条の五、第十九条の七第一項前段、第二項及び第三項、第十九条の八、第十九条の九並びに前条第一項の規定は、都道府県労働委員会について準用する。この場合において、第十九条の三第六項ただし書中「、常勤」とあるのは「、条例で定めるところにより、常勤」と、第十九条の七第二項中「内閣総理大臣」とあるのは「都道府県知事」と、「使用者委員及び労働者委員にあつては中央労働委員会の同意を得て、公益委員にあつては両議院」とあるのは「都道府県労働委員会」と、同条第三項中「内閣総理大臣」とあるのは「都道府県知事」と、「使用者委員又は労働者委員」とあるのは「都道府県労働委員会の委員」と、前条第一項中「厚生労働大臣」とあるのは「都道府県知事」と読み替えるものとする。
Article 20Authority of the Labour Relations Commission
第二十条(労働委員会の権限)
In addition to those particulars provided under the provisions of Articles 5, Article 11, and Article 18, the Labour Relations Commission has the authority to conduct examinations, etc., of unfair labor practice cases and perform conciliation, mediation and arbitration of labor disputes.
第二十一条(会議)
When a Labour Relations Commission finds it necessary for the public interest, its meetings may be opened to the public.
労働委員会は、公益上必要があると認めたときは、その会議を公開することができる。
The meetings of a Labour Relations Commission is convened by the chairperson.
労働委員会の会議は、会長が招集する。
The Labour Relations Commission may not hold a meeting nor make any decision unless one or more employer members, labor members, and public interest members are present.
Decisions are to be made by a majority of the members present, and in the case of tie in votes, the chairperson is to make the decision.
議事は、出席委員の過半数で決し、可否同数のときは、会長の決するところによる。
Article 22Compulsory Authority
第二十二条(強制権限)
If a Labour Relations Commission finds it necessary for performing its administrative affairs, it may request the attendance, submission of reports or necessary books and documents, by the employer or the employers' organization or the labor union, or other persons concerned. The Labour Relations Commission may also have its members or staff members (hereinafter simply referred to as "staff members") inspect factories and other relevant workplaces and inspect the business situations, books and documents and other objects.
労働委員会は、その事務を行うために必要があると認めたときは、使用者又はその団体、労働組合その他の関係者に対して、出頭、報告の提出若しくは必要な帳簿書類の提出を求め、又は委員若しくは労働委員会の職員(以下単に「職員」という。)に関係工場事業場に臨検し、業務の状況若しくは帳簿書類その他の物件を検査させることができる。
In cases where a Labour Relations Commission has its members or staff members inspect or investigate the places pursuant to the preceding paragraph, the Commission must require them to carry an identification card and to present the card to the persons concerned.
Article 23Obligation to Keep Secrets
第二十三条(秘密を守る義務)
Members or those who have been members, as well as staff members or those who have been staff members of a Labour Relations Commission, must not disclose any secrets obtained in relation to their duties. The same applies to local members for adjustment or those who have been local members for adjustment of the Central Labour Relations Commission.
労働委員会の委員若しくは委員であつた者又は職員若しくは職員であつた者は、その職務に関して知得した秘密を漏らしてはならない。中央労働委員会の地方調整委員又は地方調整委員であつた者も、同様とする。
Article 24Authority Executed Solely by Public Interest Members
第二十四条(公益委員のみで行う権限)
The public interest members of a Labour Relations Commission participate in the disposition of cases as prescribed in Article 5 and Article 11; examinations, etc., of unfair labor practice cases (referred to as "examinations, etc." in the following Article); and dispositions of cases as prescribed in Article 42 of the Labor Relations Adjustment Act; provided, however, that employer members and labor members may participate in the procedures for conducting an investigation (limited to cases in which the public interest members so request) and holding a hearing pursuant to the provisions of Article 27, paragraph (1) (including as applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to Article 27-17) and in the procedures for recommending a settlement pursuant to the provisions of Article 27-14, paragraph (1) (including as applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to Article 27-17), or may perform an act pursuant to the provisions of Article 27-7, paragraph (4) and Article 27-12, paragraph (2) (including as applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to Article 27-17).
第五条及び第十一条の規定による事件の処理並びに不当労働行為事件の審査等(次条において「審査等」という。)並びに労働関係調整法第四十二条の規定による事件の処理には、労働委員会の公益委員のみが参与する。ただし、使用者委員及び労働者委員は、第二十七条第一項(第二十七条の十七の規定により準用する場合を含む。)の規定により調査(公益委員の求めがあつた場合に限る。)及び審問を行う手続並びに第二十七条の十四第一項(第二十七条の十七の規定により準用する場合を含む。)の規定により和解を勧める手続に参与し、又は第二十七条の七第四項及び第二十七条の十二第二項(第二十七条の十七の規定により準用する場合を含む。)の規定による行為をすることができる。
The Central Labour Relations Commission may have public interest members serving full time investigate the situations of labor relationships of employees of an agency engaged in administrative execution, and other particulars found necessary for performing administrative affairs of the Central Labour Relations Commission, in addition to those related to the cases pending before the Central Labour Relations Commission.
第二十四条の二(合議体等)
The Central Labour Relations Commission conducts its examinations, etc., through a panel, consisting of five public interest members appointed by the chairperson.
Notwithstanding the provisions of the preceding paragraph, in cases that fall under any of the following items, a panel consisting of all public interest members conducts the examinations, etc.:
cases in which the panel set forth in the preceding paragraph finds that its opinion concerning the interpretation and application of law and regulations is opposed to dispositions imposed by the Central Labour Relations Commission pursuant to Article 5, paragraph (1) or Article 11, paragraph (1), or Article 27-12, paragraph (1) (including as applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to Article 27-17);
前項の合議体が、法令の解釈適用について、その意見が前に中央労働委員会のした第五条第一項若しくは第十一条第一項又は第二十七条の十二第一項(第二十七条の十七の規定により準用する場合を含む。)の規定による処分に反すると認めた場合
cases in which the panel set forth in the preceding paragraph cannot make its coordinated opinion because opinions of its members are divided;
前項の合議体を構成する者の意見が分かれたため、その合議体としての意見が定まらない場合
cases in which the panel set forth in the preceding paragraph finds it reasonable for a panel consisting of all public interest members to conduct examinations, etc.; and
cases in which filing of an objection pursuant to the provision of Article 27-10, paragraph 3 (including as applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to Article 27-17) are conducted proceedings.
第二十七条の十第三項(第二十七条の十七の規定により準用する場合を含む。)の規定による異議の申立てを審理する場合
A Prefectural Labour Relations Commission conducts the examinations, etc., through its panel, consisting of all public interest members; provided, however, that, as provided for by ordinance, a panel consisting of five or seven public interest members appointed by the chairperson may conduct examinations, etc. In this case, the provisions of the preceding paragraph (except items (i) and (iv)) apply mutatis mutandis to Prefectural Labour Relations Commissions.
A Labour Relations Commission, in conducting examinations, etc., in accordance with the provisions of the preceding three paragraphs, may have one or more public interest members carry out the procedures for examinations, etc., in whole or in part (excluding disposition under the provisions of Article 5, paragraph (1), Article 11, paragraph (1), Article 27-4, paragraph (1) (including as applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to Article 27-17); Article 27-7, paragraph (1) (including as applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to Article 27-17, other than parts where the parties concerned or witnesses are made to give a statement or where the submitted objects are retained); Article 27-10, paragraphs (2) and (4), and Article 27-12, paragraph (1) (including as applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to Article 27-17); and a motion under Article 27-20; the same applies in the following paragraph).
労働委員会は、前三項の規定により審査等を行うときは、一人又は数人の公益委員に審査等の手続(第五条第一項、第十一条第一項、第二十七条の四第一項(第二十七条の十七の規定により準用する場合を含む。)、第二十七条の七第一項(当事者若しくは証人に陳述させ、又は提出された物件を留め置く部分を除き、第二十七条の十七の規定により準用する場合を含む。)、第二十七条の十第二項並びに同条第四項及び第二十七条の十二第一項(第二十七条の十七の規定により準用する場合を含む。)の規定による処分並びに第二十七条の二十の申立てを除く。次項において同じ。)の全部又は一部を行わせることができる。
Among the procedures for examination, etc., carried out by the Central Labour Relations Commission, the Central Labour Relations Commission may have the local members for adjustment representing the public interest undertake the procedures in whole or in part in making an investigation and holding a hearing pursuant to the provisions of Article 27, paragraph (1) (including as applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to Article 27-17), and the procedures in whole or in part in recommending a settlement pursuant to the provisions of Article 27-14, paragraph (1) (including as applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to Article 27-17). In this case, the local members for adjustment representing the employers and the local members for adjustment representing the workers may participate in those procedures (for the procedures in conducting an investigation, limited to the case where the local members for adjustment representing the public interest so request).
Article 25Jurisdiction of the Central Labour Relations Commission
第二十五条(中央労働委員会の管轄等)
In cases concerning the labor relationships of employees of an agency engaged in administrative execution, the Central Labour Relations Commission assumes exclusive jurisdiction over the conciliation, mediation, arbitration, and disposition (for dispositions under the provisions of Article 5, paragraph (1) and Article 11, paragraph (1) concerning a labor union that is formed or joined by employees of an agency engaged in administrative execution, the dispositions are limited to those specified by Cabinet Order); and the Central Labour Relations Commission assumes priority jurisdiction over the conciliation, mediation, arbitration, and disposition of cases which extend over two or more prefectures or which are related to issues of national significance.
The Central Labour Relations Commission may re-examine the dispositions of the Prefectural Labour Relations Commission pursuant to the provisions of Articles 5, paragraph (1); Article 11, paragraph (1); and Article 27-12, paragraph (1), with full authority to rescind, approve, or modify the dispositions, or dismiss an appeal for re-examination of those dispositions. The re-examination is to be conducted based on an appeal of either party to the disposition of the Prefectural Labour Relations Commission, or by the Central Labour Commission's authority.
中央労働委員会は、第五条第一項、第十一条第一項及び第二十七条の十二第一項の規定による都道府県労働委員会の処分を取り消し、承認し、若しくは変更する完全な権限をもつて再審査し、又はその処分に対する再審査の申立てを却下することができる。この再審査は、都道府県労働委員会の処分の当事者のいずれか一方の申立てに基づいて、又は職権で、行うものとする。
第二十六条(規則制定権)
The Central Labour Relations Commission may establish rules for its procedures as well as for the Prefectural Labour Relations Commission's procedures.
中央労働委員会は、その行う手続及び都道府県労働委員会が行う手続に関する規則を定めることができる。
The Prefectural Labour Relations Commission may establish rules on matters concerning the convocation of its meetings and other particulars specified by Cabinet Order to the extent that they do not violate the regulation set forth in the preceding paragraph.
都道府県労働委員会は、前項の規則に違反しない限りにおいて、その会議の招集に関する事項その他の政令で定める事項に関する規則を定めることができる。
Section 2 Procedures for Examination of Unfair Labor Practice Cases
第二節 不当労働行為事件の審査の手続
Article 27Commencement of Examinations of Unfair Labor Practice Cases
第二十七条(不当労働行為事件の審査の開始)
If a motion that an employer has violated the provisions of Article 7 is received, the Labour Relations Commission must conduct an investigation without delay and, if it is found necessary, hold a hearing on whether there are reasons for filing the motion. In this case, sufficient opportunity to submit evidence and to cross-examine the witnesses must be given to the employer and to the movant for the procedures of the hearing.
労働委員会は、使用者が第七条の規定に違反した旨の申立てを受けたときは、遅滞なく調査を行い、必要があると認めたときは、当該申立てが理由があるかどうかについて審問を行わなければならない。この場合において、審問の手続においては、当該使用者及び申立人に対し、証拠を提出し、証人に反対尋問をする充分な機会が与えられなければならない。
A Labour Relations Commission may not accept a motion set forth in the preceding paragraph when more than one year has elapsed since the day on which the act in question was committed (in the case of a continuing act, the date on which the act was finished).
労働委員会は、前項の申立てが、行為の日(継続する行為にあつてはその終了した日)から一年を経過した事件に係るものであるときは、これを受けることができない。
Article 27-2Disqualification of Public Interest Members
第二十七条の二(公益委員の除斥)
A public interest member is disqualified from execution of duties concerning examinations in the case where the member falls under any of the following items:
公益委員は、次の各号のいずれかに該当するときは、審査に係る職務の執行から除斥される。
the public interest member, their spouse, or any person who was formerly their spouse, is or was formerly a party involved in the case or the representative of the party which is a corporation;
公益委員又はその配偶者若しくは配偶者であつた者が事件の当事者又は法人である当事者の代表者であり、又はあつたとき。
the public interest member is or was formerly a blood relative of the party within the fourth degree of kinship, a relative by marriage of the party within the third degree, or a cohabiting relative;
公益委員が事件の当事者の四親等以内の血族、三親等以内の姻族又は同居の親族であり、又はあつたとき。
the public interest member is a guardian, supervisor of a guardian, a curator, supervisor of a curator, an assistant, or supervisor of an assistant to the party involved in the case;
公益委員が事件の当事者の後見人、後見監督人、保佐人、保佐監督人、補助人又は補助監督人であるとき。
the public interest member has become a witness to the case; or
公益委員が事件について証人となつたとき。
the public interest member is or was formerly the party's agent, with regard to a pending case.
公益委員が事件について当事者の代理人であり、又はあつたとき。
If any of the causes for disqualification prescribed in the preceding paragraph apply, the party to the case may file a motion for the disqualification of the public interest member in question.
前項に規定する除斥の原因があるときは、当事者は、除斥の申立てをすることができる。
Article 27-3Challenge to Public Interest Members
第二十七条の三(公益委員の忌避)
If a public interest member has any circumstances which should preclude fair examination, the party may challenge the public interest member.
公益委員について審査の公正を妨げるべき事情があるときは、当事者は、これを忌避することができる。
The party may not challenge a public interest member after the party has made a statement in writing or orally on the case to the Labour Relations Commission; provided, however, that this does not apply to a party who did not know the existence of grounds for a challenge, or when the grounds for a challenge arose after the statement was made.
当事者は、事件について労働委員会に対し書面又は口頭をもつて陳述した後は、公益委員を忌避することができない。ただし、忌避の原因があることを知らなかつたとき、又は忌避の原因がその後に生じたときは、この限りでない。
Article 27-4Decisions on Motions for Disqualification or Challenge
第二十七条の四(除斥又は忌避の申立てについての決定)
The Labour Relations Commission makes decisions on motions for disqualification or challenge.
除斥又は忌避の申立てについては、労働委員会が決定する。
Public interest members who are involved in the motion for disqualification or challenge may not participate in the decisions set forth in the preceding paragraph; provided, however, that the members may state their opinions.
The decisions made pursuant to the provisions of paragraph (1) are to be made in writing with the reasons attached.
第一項の規定による決定は、書面によるものとし、かつ、理由を付さなければならない。
Article 27-5Suspension of the Examination Procedures
第二十七条の五(審査の手続の中止)
If a motion for disqualification or challenge has been filed, the Labour Relations Commission must suspend the examination procedures until a decision is made concerning the motion; provided, however, that this does not apply when urgent action is required.
労働委員会は、除斥又は忌避の申立てがあつたときは、その申立てについての決定があるまで審査の手続を中止しなければならない。ただし、急速を要する行為についてはこの限りでない。
第二十七条の六(審査の計画)
Prior to commencement of a hearing, the Labour Relations Commission must hear the opinions of both parties and establish an examination plan.
労働委員会は、審問開始前に、当事者双方の意見を聴いて、審査の計画を定めなければならない。
The examination plan set forth in the preceding paragraph must include the following information:
前項の審査の計画においては、次に掲げる事項を定めなければならない。
issues and evidence consolidated in the investigation procedure (including those consolidated as evidence requiring examination during the course of the subsequent examination procedure);
調査を行う手続において整理された争点及び証拠(その後の審査の手続における取調べが必要な証拠として整理されたものを含む。)
the duration and number of hearings, and the number of witnesses to be examined;
審問を行う期間及び回数並びに尋問する証人の数
scheduled timing for delivery of orders provided for in Article 27-12, paragraph (1).
第二十七条の十二第一項の命令の交付の予定時期
The Labour Relations Commission may change the examination plan upon hearing the opinions of both parties if it finds that the change is necessary in consideration of the present state of examination and other circumstances.
労働委員会は、審査の現状その他の事情を考慮して必要があると認めるときは、当事者双方の意見を聴いて、審査の計画を変更することができる。
The Labour Relations Commission and the parties must endeavor to ensure that examinations are conducted in accordance with the examination plan, so as to realize a proper and expeditious examination.
労働委員会及び当事者は、適正かつ迅速な審査の実現のため、審査の計画に基づいて審査が行われるよう努めなければならない。
Article 27-7Examination of Evidence
第二十七条の七(証拠調べ)
The Labour Relations Commission, upon motion by either party or by the Labour Relations Commission's authority, may examine evidence by the methods listed in item (ii) for the procedures for investigation, and by the methods listed in the following items for the procedures for hearings:
労働委員会は、当事者の申立てにより又は職権で、調査を行う手続においては第二号に掲げる方法により、審問を行う手続においては次の各号に掲げる方法により証拠調べをすることができる。
to order the parties or witnesses to appear and have them make statements to the extent necessary to find facts;
事実の認定に必要な限度において、当事者又は証人に出頭を命じて陳述させること。
to order the holders of those books and documents, or other objects related to the case (hereinafter referred to as the "objects") to submit the objects, without which it is found likely to be difficult to certify the facts, or to retain the objects already submitted.
事件に関係のある帳簿書類その他の物件であつて、当該物件によらなければ当該物件により認定すべき事実を認定することが困難となるおそれがあると認めるもの(以下「物件」という。)の所持者に対し、当該物件の提出を命じ、又は提出された物件を留め置くこと。
The Labour Relations Commission, when deciding whether or not to make a disposition to issue an order to submit objects pursuant to the provision of item (ii) of the preceding paragraph (hereinafter referred to as the "order to submit objects"), must take into consideration the protection of secrets of individuals and business secrets of companies.
The Labour Relations Commission, in issuing an order to submit objects, may order the submission of the objects other than the parts the submission of which it finds unnecessary or inappropriate as a result of consideration taken pursuant to the provision of the preceding paragraph.
Employer members and labor members who participate in the procedure for investigations or hearings may state opinions when the Labour Relations Commission intends to issue an order to the parties or witnesses to appear pursuant to the provisions of paragraph 1, item (i) (hereinafter referred to as the "order to appear as witnesses, etc."), or intends to order the submission of the objects.
The Labour Relations Commission, when it has examined evidence by its authority, must hear the opinions of the parties about the results of the examination.
労働委員会は、職権で証拠調べをしたときは、その結果について、当事者の意見を聴かなければならない。
The motion for an order to submit objects must be filed with clarification of the following information:
物件提出命令の申立ては、次に掲げる事項を明らかにしてしなければならない。
facts to be proved.
証明すべき事実
The Labour Relations Commission, before issuing an order to submit objects, must interrogate the holders of the objects.
The Labour Relations Commission, when issuing an order to submit objects, must clarify the information listed in each item (except for item (iii)) of paragraph 6.
第二十七条の八
The Labour Relations Commission, when having witnesses give a statement, must have them take an oath.
労働委員会が証人に陳述させるときは、その証人に宣誓をさせなければならない。
The Labour Relations Commission, when having the parties give a statement, may have them take an oath.
労働委員会が当事者に陳述させるときは、その当事者に宣誓をさせることができる。
第二十七条の九
The provisions of Article 196, Article 197, and Article 201 paragraphs (2) to (4) of the Code of Civil Procedure (Act No. 109 of 1996) apply mutatis mutandis to the procedures whereby a Labour Relations Commission has witnesses give a statement. The provisions of Article 201, paragraph (2) as applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to the provisions of Article 210 of the same Act apply mutatis mutandis to the procedure in which a Labour Relations Commission has the parties give a statement.
民事訴訟法(平成八年法律第百九号)第百九十六条、第百九十七条及び第二百一条第二項から第四項までの規定は、労働委員会が証人に陳述させる手続に、同法第二百十条の規定において準用する同法第二百一条第二項の規定は、労働委員会が当事者に陳述させる手続について準用する。
第二十七条の十(不服の申立て)
When persons have received an order to appear as witnesses, etc., or an order to submit objects from a Prefectural Labour Relations Commission (hereinafter referred to as an "order, etc., to appear as witnesses, etc." in this Article) and are dissatisfied with the order, etc., to appear as witnesses, etc., those persons may appeal to the Central Labour Relations Commission in writing for examination stating the reasons within one week from the day when they received the order, etc., to appear as witnesses, etc., (when there are compelling reasons such as natural disaster for not appealing within that period, within one week from the day following the date the reasons have ceased to exist).
In the case that the Central Labour Relations Commission finds that there is a reason for the appeal for examination pursuant to the provisions of the preceding paragraph, it shall rescind the whole or part of the order, etc., to appear as witnesses, etc.
When persons have received an order, etc., to appear as witnesses, etc., from the Central Labour Relations Commission and are dissatisfied with the order, the persons may file a written objection to the Central Labour Relations Commission, stating the reasons within one week from the day when they received the order, etc., to appear as witnesses, etc. (when there are compelling reasons such as natural disaster for not appealing within that period, within one week from the day following the date the reasons have ceased).
中央労働委員会の証人等出頭命令等を受けた者は、証人等出頭命令等について不服があるときは、証人等出頭命令等を受けた日から一週間以内(天災その他この期間内に異議の申立てをしなかつたことについてやむを得ない理由があるときは、その理由がやんだ日の翌日から起算して一週間以内)に、その理由を記載した書面により、中央労働委員会に異議を申し立てることができる。
In the case that the Central Labour Relations Commission finds that there is a reason for filing of an objection pursuant to the provisions of the preceding paragraph, it rescinds the whole or part of the order, etc., to appear as witnesses, etc., or modifies the order.
The proceedings of request for examination or filing of an objection is executed in writing.
審査の申立て又は異議の申立ての審理は、書面による。
The Central Labour Relations Commission may interrogate persons who request examination or file an objection by its authority.
中央労働委員会は、職権で審査申立人又は異議申立人を審尋することができる。
Article 27-11Maintenance of Order at Hearing Tribunal
第二十七条の十一(審問廷の秩序維持)
The Labour Relations Committee may order persons interfering hearings to leave the courtroom, and take other necessary measures to maintain order at hearing tribunals.
労働委員会は、審問を妨げる者に対し退廷を命じ、その他審問廷の秩序を維持するために必要な措置を執ることができる。
第二十七条の十二(救済命令等)
The Labour Relations Commission, when the case is ready to issue of an order, must certify the facts and, on the basis of the certification, admit the whole or part of the relief related to the request of the movant, or issue an order to dismiss the motion (hereinafter referred to as the "order for relief, etc.").
労働委員会は、事件が命令を発するのに熟したときは、事実の認定をし、この認定に基づいて、申立人の請求に係る救済の全部若しくは一部を認容し、又は申立てを棄却する命令(以下「救済命令等」という。)を発しなければならない。
Employer members and labor members who participate in the procedure for an investigation or hearing may state opinions in the case that the Labour Relations Commission intends to issue an order for relief, etc.
The certification of facts and the order for relief, etc. set forth in paragraph (1) is to be executed in writing, and their copies must be delivered to the employer and the movant.
An order for relief, etc. becomes effective on the day of the delivery.
救済命令等は、交付の日から効力を生ずる。
Article 27-13Finalizing an Order for Relief
第二十七条の十三(救済命令等の確定)
An order for relief, etc. becomes final and binding when the employer has not filed an action for rescission provided by Article 27-19, paragraph (1) within the period set forth in the same paragraph.
使用者が救済命令等について第二十七条の十九第一項の期間内に同項の取消しの訴えを提起しないときは、救済命令等は、確定する。
If the employer does not accede to the final and binding order for relief, etc., the Labour Relations Commission must notify the district court with jurisdiction over the location of the employer to that effect. Labor unions and workers may also make this notification.
第二十七条の十四(和解)
The Labor Relations Commission may recommend settlement to the parties at any time in the course of the examination.
労働委員会は、審査の途中において、いつでも、当事者に和解を勧めることができる。
When a settlement has been established between the parties and both parties make motions before the order for relief, etc. becomes final and binding, and when the Labour Relations Commission finds that the content of the settlement is appropriate to maintain or establish normal order of labor relationships between the parties, the examination procedure is terminated.
救済命令等が確定するまでの間に当事者間で和解が成立し、当事者双方の申立てがあつた場合において、労働委員会が当該和解の内容が当事者間の労働関係の正常な秩序を維持させ、又は確立させるため適当と認めるときは、審査の手続は終了する。
In cases as prescribed in the preceding paragraph, the order for relief, etc. already issued for the case related to the settlement (limited to the settlement that the Labour Relations Commission finds appropriate pursuant to the provisions of the preceding paragraph; the same applies in the following paragraph) ceases to be effective.
The Labour Relations Commission, in the case that a settlement includes agreement on payments of a certain amount of money or delivery of a certain quantity of fungible things or securities, draw up a record of settlement concerning the agreement upon request from both parties.
労働委員会は、和解に金銭の一定額の支払又はその他の代替物若しくは有価証券の一定の数量の給付を内容とする合意が含まれる場合は、当事者双方の申立てにより、当該合意について和解調書を作成することができる。
The record of settlement prescribed in the preceding paragraph, where compulsory execution is concerned, is deemed to be the title of obligation listed in Article 22, item (v) of the Civil Execution Act (Act No. 4 of 1979).
前項の和解調書は、強制執行に関しては、民事執行法(昭和五十四年法律第四号)第二十二条第五号に掲げる債務名義とみなす。
Granting of certificate of execution concerning the title of obligation set forth in the preceding paragraph is performed by the chairperson of the Labour Relations Commission. The service pursuant to the second sentence of Article 29 of the Civil Enforcement Act is to be made in the same way.
前項の規定による債務名義についての執行文の付与は、労働委員会の会長が行う。民事執行法第二十九条後段の送達も、同様とする。
Trial on objections concerning the granting of the certificate of execution, pursuant to the provisions of the preceding paragraph, is to be conducted at the district court having jurisdiction over the location of the Labour Relations Commission.
前項の規定による執行文付与に関する異議についての裁判は、労働委員会の所在地を管轄する地方裁判所においてする。
Particulars necessary for the service of the record of settlement set forth in paragraph (4) and for the service pursuant to the second sentence of paragraph (6) are specified by Cabinet Order.
Article 27-15Request for Re-examination
第二十七条の十五(再審査の申立て)
When receiving order for relief, etc. from a Prefectural Labour Relations Commission, employers may request re-examination to the Central Labour Relations Commission within fifteen days (if there are compelling reasons, such as natural disaster for not making a request within that period, within one week from the day following the date the reasons ceased to exist); provided, however, that the request does not suspend the validity of the order for relief, etc., and the order for relief, etc. ceases to be effective when the Central Labour Relations Commission rescinds or modifies the order as a result of re-examination conducted pursuant to the provisions of Article 25, paragraph (2).
The provisions of the preceding paragraph apply mutatis mutandis to requests for re-examination by labor unions or workers of the Central Labour Relations Commission.
Article 27-16Relations between Re-examination and Lawsuit
第二十七条の十六(再審査と訴訟との関係)
The Central Labour Relations Commission may not re-examine an order for relief, etc. when the whole or part of the order for relief, etc. by a Prefectural Labour Relations Commission is supported by a final and binding judgment based on the action pursuant to Article 27-19, paragraph (1).
中央労働委員会は、第二十七条の十九第一項の訴えに基づく確定判決によつて都道府県労働委員会の救済命令等の全部又は一部が支持されたときは、当該救済命令等について、再審査することができない。
Article 27-17Application Mutatis Mutandis to the Procedure for Re-examination
第二十七条の十七(再審査の手続への準用)
The provisions of Article 27, paragraph (1); Article 27-2 through Article 27-9; Article 27-10, paragraphs (3) through (6); and Article 27-11 through Article 27-14 apply mutatis mutandis to the procedure for re-examination taken by the Central Labour Relations Commission. In this case, the phrase "when the public member bears witness to the case" in Article 27-2, paragraph (1), item (iv) is deemed to be replaced with "when the public member bears witness to the case, or when the public member gets involved in the order for relief, etc. of a Prefectural Labour Relations Commission which has already been issued for the case."
第二十七条第一項、第二十七条の二から第二十七条の九まで、第二十七条の十第三項から第六項まで及び第二十七条の十一から第二十七条の十四までの規定は、中央労働委員会の再審査の手続について準用する。この場合において、第二十七条の二第一項第四号中「とき」とあるのは「とき又は事件について既に発せられている都道府県労働委員会の救済命令等に関与したとき」と読み替えるものとする。
Article 27-18Period of Examination
第二十七条の十八(審査の期間)
The Labour Relations Commission, for the purpose of conducting expeditious examinations, is to set a target for the period of examination, and publicize the degree of achievement of the target and any other implementation status of the examination.
労働委員会は、迅速な審査を行うため、審査の期間の目標を定めるとともに、目標の達成状況その他の審査の実施状況を公表するものとする。
Section 3 Lawsuits
第三節 訴訟
Article 27-19Filing an Action for Rescission
第二十七条の十九(取消しの訴え)
When an employer has not requested the Central Labour Relations Commission to review an order for relief, etc. by the Prefectural Labour Relations Commission, or when the Central Labour Relations Commission has issued an order for relief, etc., the employer may file an action for rescission of the order for relief, etc. within thirty days from the day on which the order-for-relief, etc. was delivered. This period is unextendable.
使用者が都道府県労働委員会の救済命令等について中央労働委員会に再審査の申立てをしないとき、又は中央労働委員会が救済命令等を発したときは、使用者は、救済命令等の交付の日から三十日以内に、救済命令等の取消しの訴えを提起することができる。この期間は、不変期間とする。
When an employer has requested the Central Labour Relations Commission to re-examine an order pursuant to the provisions of Article 27-15, paragraph (1), the employer may file an action for rescission only against the order for relief, etc. by the Central Labour Relations Commission for that request. The provisions of Article 12, paragraphs (3) through paragraph (5) of the Administrative Case Litigation Act (Act No. 139 of 1962) do not apply to this action.
使用者は、第二十七条の十五第一項の規定により中央労働委員会に再審査の申立てをしたときは、その申立てに対する中央労働委員会の救済命令等に対してのみ、取消しの訴えを提起することができる。この訴えについては、行政事件訴訟法(昭和三十七年法律第百三十九号)第十二条第三項から第五項までの規定は、適用しない。
The provisions of the preceding paragraph apply mutatis mutandis to actions for rescission filed by labor unions or workers, pursuant to the Administrative Case Litigation Act.
第二十七条の二十(緊急命令)
In the case where an employer has filed an action to a court pursuant to the provisions of paragraph (1) of the preceding Article, the court in charge of the case, at the request of the Labour Relations Commission which has issued the order for relief, etc., may order the employer to comply with the whole or part of the order for relief, etc. in accordance with a ruling until the judgment becomes final and binding, or rescind or modify this ruling upon the request from the parties or by its authority.
Article 27-21Restrictions on Offer of Evidences
第二十七条の二十一(証拠の申出の制限)
A person who has not submitted an object notwithstanding the order to submit objects by the Labour Relations Commission (excluding persons who are not the party to the procedure for examination) may not offer evidence for the object to the court to prove facts which could be certified by the object specified in the order to submit objects; provided, however, that this does not apply when it is found that there are legitimate grounds for not submitting the object.
Section 4 Miscellaneous Provisions
第四節 雑則
Article 27-22Recommendations of the Central Labour Relations Commission
第二十七条の二十二(中央労働委員会の勧告等)
The Central Labour Relations Commission may request a Prefectural Labour Relations Commission to report on administrative affairs conducted by the Prefectural Labour Relations Commission pursuant to the provisions of this Act, or make recommendations, give advice, provide training of members and staff members of the secretariat, or provide any other assistance necessary for the application of laws and regulations and for conducting those administrative affairs.
中央労働委員会は、都道府県労働委員会に対し、この法律の規定により都道府県労働委員会が処理する事務について、報告を求め、又は法令の適用その他当該事務の処理に関して必要な勧告、助言若しくはその委員若しくは事務局職員の研修その他の援助を行うことができる。
In a lawsuit in which a prefecture is the defendant pursuant to the provisions of Article 11, paragraph (1) of the Administrative Case Litigation Act (including as applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to Article 38, paragraph (1) of the same Act; the same applies in the following paragraph) related to the disposition (meaning dispositions pursuant to the provisions of Article 3, paragraph (2) of the same Act and including dispositions imposed by public interest members pursuant to the provisions of Article 24-2, paragraph (4) and dispositions imposed by local members for adjustment representing public interests pursuant to the provisions of paragraph (5) of the same Article; the same applies in the following paragraph), the Prefectural Labour Relations Commission represents the prefecture.
都道府県労働委員会は、その処分(行政事件訴訟法第三条第二項に規定する処分をいい、第二十四条の二第四項の規定により公益委員がした処分及び同条第五項の規定により公益を代表する地方調整委員がした処分を含む。次項において同じ。)に係る行政事件訴訟法第十一条第一項(同法第三十八条第一項において準用する場合を含む。次項において同じ。)の規定による都道府県を被告とする訴訟について、当該都道府県を代表する。
The Prefectural Labour Relations Commission may designate persons from among its public interest members, directors-general or staff members of its secretariat, and have them file an action regarding the disposition of Prefectural Labour Relations Commission pursuant to the provisions of Article 11, paragraph (1) of the Administrative Case Litigation Act in which a prefecture is the defendant, or file an action in which the Prefectural Labour Relations Commission is a party.
都道府県労働委員会は、公益委員、事務局長又は事務局の職員でその指定するものに都道府県労働委員会の処分に係る行政事件訴訟法第十一条第一項の規定による都道府県を被告とする訴訟又は都道府県労働委員会を当事者とする訴訟を行わせることができる。
Article 27-24Reimbursement of Expenses
第二十七条の二十四(費用弁償)
A person who has been required to appear pursuant to the provisions of Article 22, paragraph (1) or a witness pursuant to Article 27-7, paragraph (1), item (i) (including as applied mutatis mutandis pursuant to Article 27-17), may be compensated for the expenses as specified by Cabinet Order.
第二十二条第一項の規定により出頭を求められた者又は第二十七条の七第一項第一号(第二十七条の十七の規定により準用する場合を含む。)の証人は、政令の定めるところにより、費用の弁償を受けることができる。
Article 27-25Exclusion from Application of the Administrative Procedure Act
第二十七条の二十五(行政手続法の適用除外)
The provisions of Chapter 2 and Chapter 3 of the Administrative Procedure Act (Act No. 88 of 1993) do not apply to dispositions imposed by a Labour Relations Commission (including dispositions imposed by public interest members pursuant to the provisions of Article 24-2, paragraph (4) of this Act and dispositions imposed by local members for adjustment representing public interests pursuant to the provisions of paragraph (5) of the same Article).
労働委員会がする処分(第二十四条の二第四項の規定により公益委員がする処分及び同条第五項の規定により公益を代表する地方調整委員がする処分を含む。)については、行政手続法(平成五年法律第八十八号)第二章及び第三章の規定は、適用しない。
Article 27-26Limitation on Requests for Review
第二十七条の二十六(審査請求の制限)
No request for review may be made against the dispositions imposed by a Labour Relations Commission (including dispositions imposed by public interest members pursuant to the provisions of Article 24-2, paragraph (4) of this Act and dispositions imposed by local members for adjustment representing public interests pursuant to the provisions of paragraph (5) of the same Article) or against its inaction.
労働委員会がする処分(第二十四条の二第四項の規定により公益委員がする処分及び同条第五項の規定により公益を代表する地方調整委員がする処分を含む。)又はその不作為については、審査請求をすることができない。